¡]¥»¤å§@ªÌ¬°¶³ªL¬ì§Þ¤j¾Ç¬ì§Þªk«ß¬ã¨s©Ò±Ð±Â¡^2022¦~5¤ë18¤é¡A¯Ã¬ù«n°Ï¦a°Ïªk°|§P¨M¤F¥@¬É¤W²Ä¤@°_NFT¡]«D¦P½è³f¹ô¡^¾P°â¯A¤Î«I®`°Ó¼Ðªº®×¨Ò¡C¸Ó®×¤¤¡A·R°¨¥K¡]Herm ás¡^±±§i¤@¦WÃÀ³N®a¡A¥L³Ð§@¤F¤@¨t¦Cªº·R°¨¥K¬fª÷¥]ªº¦UºØµe§@¡A¨ú¦W¬°¡uMetaBirkins¡v¨t¦C¡A¥HNFT¦bºô¸ô¤W¾P°â¡C¸ÓÃÀ³N®a½Ð¨Dª½±µ»é¦^¸Ó¶D³^¡A¦ýªk°|µô©w»{¬°À³¨ü²z¸Ó¶D³^¡C
ÃÀ³N®a³Ð§@MetaBirkins¨t¦C¼Æ¦ì³Ð§@
³o°_®×¥ó¦W¬°Herm ás International, et al. v Mason Rothschild®×¡C¦ÛºÙ¬°Mason Rothschildªºµe®a¡A¥H·R°¨¥K¸g¨å´Ú¬fª÷¥]¡]Birkin¡^ªº¥~«¬¡A´«¤W¤ò¯ñ¯ñªº§÷½è¡A·f¤W¤£¦P°t¦â¡A³Ð§@¤F¤@¨t¦C¼Æ¦ìµe§@¡C¥L±N³o¨Ç¼Æ¦ìµe§@©R¦W¬°MetaBirkins¨t¦C¡A¨C¤@´Tµe§@¦³¤@Ó½s¸¹¡A¨Ã¥HNFTªº¤è¦¡¡A¦bNFTªº¾P°âºô¯¸OpenSea¤W³c°â¡C¥H¤U¬O¸Óºô¯¸¾P°âªººI¹Ï¡C
¹Ï¤@¡BOpenSeaºô¯¸¤W¾P°âªºMetaBirkins¨t¦C°Ó«~¡C ¹Ï¤ù¨Ó·½¡GOpenSeaºô¯¸
·R°¨¥K¥D±i«I®`¨äBirkin°Ó¼Ð
·R°¨¥K¥D±i¡ARothschild¾P°â³o¨Ç¦W¬°MetaBirkin ªºNFT¡A«I®`¨Ã´î·l¡]diluted¡^¤F·R°¨¥Kªº¬fª÷°Ó¼Ð¡A¿ù»~«ü¥Ü³o¨ÇNFTªº¨Ó·½¡AÅý¤H¥H¬°³o¨Ç¬O·R°¨¥K±ÂÅvªº¼Æ¦ì°Ó«~¡A¶Ë®`¥B´î·l¤F·R°¨¥Kªº°ÓÅA¡C¥t¥~¡A·R°¨¥K¤]¥D±i¡ARothschild¨Ï¥Îmetabirkins.com³oÓºô§}¨Ó¾P°â³o¨ÇNFT¼Æ¦ìµe§@¡Aºc¦¨¤F¤£·íªººô§}·mµù¥U¦æ¬°¡C
³Q§i¥D±iÄÝÃÀ³N³Ð§@ÁŧK¡A½Ð¨Dªk°|ª½±µ»é¦^¸Ó®×
³Q§iRothschild«h½Ð¨Dª½±µ»é¦^¸Ó¶D³^¡]moved to dismiss¡^¡C¨ä²z¥Ñ¥Dn¬O¡A¥L¨Ï¥Î¡uMetaBirkin¡v°µ¬°µe§@¦WºÙ¡Aºc¦¨¤F°Ó¼ÐªºÃÀ³N³Ð§@¨Ï¥Î¡A²Å¦X²Ä¤G¨µ°jªk°|1989¦~Rogers v. Grimaldi®×ªº¼Ð·Ç¡C
²Ä¤G¨µ°jªk°|¦b1989¦~ªºRogers v. Grimaldi®×¡A«Ø¥ß¤FÃÀ³N³Ð§@ÁŧK«I®`°Ó¼Ðªº¼Ð·Ç¡C¸Ó®×ªºì§i¬O¤@ÓµÛ¦Wºtû¡A¥L¥D±i¦Û¤vªº¦W¦r¦³§Î¶HÅv¡]©ÎºÙ¨v¹³Åv¡^¡A¨Ã¥D±i¹q¼v¤½¥q»s§@ªº¹q¼v¡mGinger and Fred¡n«I®`¤F¥Lªº§Î¶HÅv¡CRogers®×«Ø¥ß¤F¤G¨BÆJÀË´úªk¡C²Ä¤@¨BÆJ¡A¬O¬Ý¸Ó°Ó¼Ð¹ï³Q§i³Ð§@¡A¬O§_¨ã¦³¡u³Ì§Cµ{«×ªºÃÀ³N¬ÛÃö©Ê¡v¡]minimally artistically relevant¡^¡F²Ä¤G¨BÆJ¡A¦pªG¨ã¦³¬Y¨ÇÃÀ³N¬ÛÃö©Ê¡A«h¦b¬Ý¸Ó³Ð§@¹ï°Ó¼Ðªº¨Ï¥Î¡A¬O§_·|©úÅã¦a»~¾É¡]explicitly misleads¡^®ø¶OªÌ¡AÅý¥L̲V²c¸Ó§@«~¤§¤º®e¡B§@ªÌ¡BÃÙ§UªÌ¡BI®ÑªÌ¡C
Rothschild¥D±i¡A¥Lªº¨t¦C§@«~¡mMetaBirkins¡n¨Ï¥ÎBirkin³oӰӼСA»P¥L·Q±´°Qªº®É©|²£·~h«Ý°Êª«©M°ø¨×©M»ùȪº¥»½è¡A¦³³Ì§Cµ{«×ªºÃö³s©Ê¡C¦Ó¥B¥Lªº¨Ï¥Î¨Ã¨S¦³³y¦¨©úÅ㪺»~¾É¡A¤£½×¬Y¨ÇÆ[¬ÝªÌ¬O§_¯uªº²£¥Í²V²c¡C
·R°¨¥K»{¬°¤£²Å¦XÃÀ³N³Ð§@ÁŧK
·R°¨¥K«h»{¬°¡A¥»®×¤¤³Q§iªº¨Ï¥Î¡A¤D¹L«×ªº°Ó·~©Ê¨Ï¥Î¡A¥]¬A³Ð³y¡uMetaBirkins¡v³oÓ¼ÐÅÒ¡A¥H¸Ó¼ÐÅÒ¾P°â¼Æ¦ì²£«~¡A¸gÀç¼Æ¦ì©±±¡A¥Î¸Ó¦WºÙ¶i¦æ¦æ¾P«Å¶Çµ¥¡C·R°¨¥K¤]±j½Õ¡A¦³ÃÒ¾Ú¥i¤ä«ù¡A¦³³¡¤À®ø¶OªÌ©M²£·~Æ[¹îªÌ¹ï¸Ó¡mMetaBirkins¡n¨t¦CªºNFT¨Ó·½©M±ÂÅv²£¥Í²V²c»~»{¡C¥t¥~¡A·R°¨¥K¤]¤Þ¥Î¸ÓÃÀ³N®a¦Û¤v¦bYahoo! Finance¤W³ø¾É¤¤Á¿ªº¸Ü¡A¥L»¡¡mMetaBirkins¡n¬O¤@ӼƦì°Ó«~¡A¨Ã»{¬°¦b²{¹ê¥Í¬¡¤¤¾Ö¦³¡uºÆ¨gªº¤â´£¥]¡v¡A©Î¡u²{¦b¡v¡u¯à°÷³z¹L³o¨Ç¼Ð»x©ÊªºNFT±N¨ä±a¤JµêÀÀ¥@¬É¡v¤§¶¡¨Ã¨S¦³¡u¤Ó¤jªº°Ï§O¡v¡A¨Ã©ê«è¤H̾P°â°²«_ªº¡mMetaBirkins¡nNFT»P¥LªºNFTÄvª§¡C
·R°¨¥K¥D±i¡A²Ä¤G¨µ°jªk°|ªºRogers®×ªºÃÀ³N³Ð§@ÁŧK¡A¨Ã¤£¾A¥Î©ó°Ó·~¤W¾P°âªº¡u°Ó«~¡v¡]commodity¡^¡A¨Ò¦p¥»®×ªºNFT¼Æ¦ì§@«~¡C¨ä»{¬°¡A´Nºâ¥i¥H¾A¥ÎRogers®×¤§ÃÀ³N³Ð§@ÁŧK¡Aªk°|¤´»Ýn®Ú¾Ú²V²c»~»{¤§¸·§PÂ_ªºPolaroid®×¤K¦]¯À¡Aµû¦ô¡uMetaBirkin¡v³oÓ¼ÐÅÒ¬O§_·|¹ï¤½²³²£¥Í²V²c»~»{¤§¸·¡C
³Q§iRothschildªº¦^À³«h¬O¡A¨ä°í«ù¡mMetaBirkins¡nNFT¬OÃÀ³N§@«~¡AÀ³¥i¾A¥ÎRogers®×¤§ÃÀ³N³Ð§@ÁŧK¡A¥B¹ï§@«~¥»¨¡A©M¾P°â§@«~ªº«Å¶Ç¡A³£À³¥µ¥¹ï«Ý¡C³Q§i¨Ã¥D±i¡AÕY¥i¥H¾A¥ÎRogers®×¤§ÃÀ³N³Ð§@ÁŧK¡A«h¤£»Ýn¦A¶i¦æ²V²c»~»{¤K¦]¯ÀÀË´ú¡A¦]¬°¦bRogers®×ªº¼Ð·Ç¤U¡A¥u»Ýn°Ý¨ä¨Ï¥Î¬O§_¡u©úÅã¦a»~¾É¤½²³¡v¡A¦Ó¤£¬On°Ý¬O§_¦³²V²c»~»{¤§¸·¡A©Î¬O§_¦³¯u¥¿²V²c»~»{ªº±¡ªp¥X²{¡C
¯Ã¬ù«n°Ï¦a°Ïªk°|ªk°|µô©w¨ü²z¥»®×
¥»®×¯Ã¬ù«n°Ï¦a°Ïªk°|ªk©xJed S. Rakoff©ó2022¦~5¤ë4¤éÅ¥¨úÂù¤è¤fÀYÅG½×¡A©ó5¤ë5¤éµô©w»é¦^¡u³Q§i¤£¨ü²z¤§½Ð¨D¡v¡A¨Ã©ó5¤ë18¤é¤½¥¬¡u³Æ§Ñ©R¥O¡v¡A»¡©ú¨äµô©w¤§²z¥Ñ¡C
NFT¼Æ¦ì³Ð§@¦³¾÷·|¾A¥ÎÃÀ³N³Ð§@ÁŧK
Rakoffªk©x»{¬°¡A¤â´£¥]ªº¼Æ¦ì¹Ï¹³¡A¤]¥i¥Hºc¦¨¤@ºØÃÀ³Nªí¹F§Î¦¡¡A©Ò¥H¥i¾A¥ÎRogers®×¤§ÃÀ³N³Ð§@ÁŧK¡CRakoffªk©x«ü¥X¡ARothschild¨Ï¥ÎNFT¥H»{ÃÒ³o¨Ç¹Ï¹³¡A¨Ã¤£·|¡u§ïÅÜÃÀ³N³Ð§@ÁŧKªº¾A¥Î¡A¦]¬° NFT ¥u¬O«ü¦V¼Æ¦ì¹Ï¹³©Ò¦b¦ì¸m¨ÃÅçÃҹϹ³ªº¥N½X¡A¦]¦¹¨Ï¥Î NFT ¨ÓÅçÃҹϹ³¨Ã¤¹³\¥i°l•Wªº«áÄòÂà°â©MÂàÅý¡A¤£·|¨Ï¹Ï¹³¦¨¬°¤£¨ü¨¥½×¦Û¥Ñ«OÅ@ªº¡y°Ó«~¡z¡]commodity¡^¡A´N¹³¥X°â¹êÅéøµeªº¦³½s¸¹ªº°Æ¥»¤@¼Ë¡A¤£·|¨Ï¨ä¦¨¬°¡y°Ó«~¡z¦ÓµLªk¾A¥ÎÃÀ³N³Ð§@ÁŧK¡C¡v
¬O§_¯uªº¨ã¦³ÃÀ³N¬ÛÃö©Ê¡H
Rakoffªk©x«ü¥X¡ARogers®×©Ò«Ø¥ßªºÃÀ³N³Ð§@ÁŧKªº¤G¨BÆJÀË´ú¤¤¡A²Ä¤@¨BÀË´úªº¡uÃÀ³N¬ÛÃö©Ê¡v¼Ð·Ç«Ü§C¡C¤£¹L¡A·R°¨¥K¥D±i¡A³Q§i¨Ï¥ÎMetaBirkins³oÓ¼ÐÃÑ¡A§¹¥þ´N¬O·Qn¸ò·R°¨¥KªºBirkin°Ó¼Ðªºª¾¦W«×©M°ÓÅA³sµ²¡A¦Ó«D¥u¬O¦]¬°ÃÀ³N¤WªºÃö³s©Ê¡CRakoffªk©x¤Þ¥Î³Q§i¦Û¤v¹ï´CÅ骺»¡©ú¡A¨ä´£¨ì¡A¥L§V¤O¡uÅý¸Ó¼Æ¦ì°Ó«~³Ð³y¥X»P¬fª÷¥]¦b²{¹ê¥Í¬¡¤¤¨ã¦³ªº¨ººØ¤Ûı¡C¡v¦]¦¹¡A¨ì©³¨Ï¥Î¡uMetaBirkins¡v³oÓµü¬O§_¨ã¦³ÃÀ³NÃö³s©Ê¡A ªk©x»{¬°»Ýn¶i¦æ¼f§P¤~¯à¥[¥H§PÂ_¡C
¤w¸g¹ï¤½²³²£¥Í©úÅã»~¾É
¦Ü©ó²Ä¤G¨BÆJ¡A¬O§_¹ï¤½²³²£¥Í¡u©úÅ㪺»~¾É¡v¡ARakoffªk©x»{¬°¡A·R°¨¥K¤w¸g¾A·í¦a¥D±i¡AMetaBirkin³oÓ¼ÐÅÒ½T¹ê¦³©úÅã¦a»~¾É¡C
³Q§i¥D±i¡A²Ä¤G¨µ°jªk°|¤Uªºªk°|¡A¦b§PÂ_Rogers®×ÀË´ú¼Ð·Ç¤Uªº¡u¬O§_¦³©úÅã»~¾É¡v®É¡A¤£À³¸Ó¶i¦æPolaroid®×¤§²V²c»~»{¤K¦]¯Àªº§PÂ_¡CRakoffªk©x©ú½T«ü¥X¡A³oÓ¥D±i¬O¿ù»~ªº¡A¦b§PÂ_¦³µL©úÅã»~¾É®É¡AÀ³¸Ó¶i¦æ²V²c»~»{¤§¸·ªº¦h¦]¯À§PÂ_¡C
¦¹¥~¡ARakoffªk©x»{¬°¡A·R°¨¥K¤D¾A·í¦a¤Þ¥ÎPolaroid®×¤U¦h¦]¯À¤¤ªº¬Y¨Ç¦]¯À¡A¤ä«ù³Q§i¨Ï¥ÎªºMetaBirkin ¼ÐÃѬO»~¾Éªº¡C§Y«K³Q§i¥D±i¦¹®É¤£À³¾A¥Î²V²c»~»{¤K¦]¯À§PÂ_ ¡ARakoffªk©x±j½Õ¡A¤´µMÀ³¸Ó¨ü²z¥»®×¡A¦]¬°·R°¨¥K¤w¸g¾A·í¦a¥D±i¨¬°÷ªº¹ê»Ú¤W²V²c±¡¨Æ¡A¥H¤Î³Q§i»~¾É¤½²³ªº¨¬°÷§V¤O¡A¥]¬A³Q§i¦Û¤v¹ï´CÅ骺µo¨¥µ¥¡C
¥»®×¥i¯à¬ONFT¼Æ¦ì³Ð§@¤Þµoªº°Ó¼Ð«IÅvª§Ä³¡A¥Ñªk°|°µ¥Xªº²Ä¤@¥ó§P¨M¡C«áÄòµo®iȱo§ÚÌÄ~ÄòÃöª`¡C