¡]¥»¤å§@ªÌ¬°¶³ªL¬ì§Þ¤j¾Ç¬ì§Þªk«ß¬ã¨s©Ò±Ð±Â¡^·í½u¤W¥¥x½æ®a«I®`°Ó¼ÐÅv®É¡A½u¤W¥¥x¬O§_nt³d¥ô¡H¦U°êªk°|¹L¥h»{¬°¡A¥un¥¥x¬O³Q°Ê´£¨ÑªA°È¡A¤£¿n·¥¤¶¤J¡A«IÅvªº¥u¬O½æ®a¡A¥¥xµL±et³d¡C¦ý¬O·í¥¥x©Ò´£¨ÑªA°È¶V¨Ó¶V¦h¡A¥¥x¤´¤£»Ýt³d¡H¼Ú¬wªk°|2022¦~12¤ë22¤é°µ¥XC-148/21- Louboutin®×§P¨M[1]¡A»{¬°¨È°¨»¹¡]Amazon¡^¥i¯àn¬°½æ®aªº°Ó¼Ð«IÅvt³d¡C
¨È°¨»¹ªº²V¦X°Ó·~¼Ò¦¡
¨È°¨»¹°Ó«°¬O¥þ²yª¾¦Wªº½u¤W°Ó«°¡A°£¤F³c°â¦Û¦³«~µP°Ó«~¥~¡A¤]¤¹³\²Ä¤T¤è°Ó®a¦b¨ä°Ó«°¤W³c°â°Ó«~¡C
¨È°¨»¹±Ä¨úªº¬O¤@ºØ¡u²V¦X¼Ò¦¡¡v¡C¤@¡A¨ä¥»¨Ó¬O¦Û¤vªº½u¤W¾P°âºô¯¸¡]online sales website¡^¡A¥H¦Û¦³¦W¸q³c°â°Ó«~¡F¤G¡A«á¨ÓÂX¥R¤F¹q¤l¥«¶°¡]online marketplace¡^¥\¯à¡AÅý¨ä¥L²Ä¤T¤è½æ®a¤]¥i¦b¦¹ºô¯¸¤W¾P°â¡F²Ä¤T¤è½æ®a¾P°â²£«~®É¡A¨È°¨»¹´£¨Ñ¥¥x»P¬ÛÃöªA°È¡A¥]¬AÀx¦s¡B°t°e°Ó«~¡B°Ó«~°h³fµ¥[2]¡C
ì§i¬õ¦â°ª¸ò¾c³]p®vChristian Louboutin
¥»®×ì§i¬Oªk°êª¾¦Wªº³]p®vChristian Louboutin¡A¨ä¯S¦³ªº³]p´N¬O±N¬õ¦â¡u18¡V1663TP¦â¸¹¡v¨Ï¥Î©ó°ª¸ò¾c©³¡A¦b2005¦~µù¥U¤F¿c²ü¤ñ°Ïªº°Ó¼Ð¡A2016¦~¥Ó½Ð¨ì¼Ú·ù°Ó¼Ð[3]¡C
¨È°¨»¹ºô¯¸¤W©Ò¾P°â°Ó«~¡A±`±`¥X²{«I®`¨ä¬õ¦â¾c©³°Ó¼Ðªº²£«~¡C¦]¦¹¡AChristian Louboutin¤À§O¦b¿c´Ë³ù©M¤ñ§Q®Éªk°|´£°_¶D³^¡C¿c´Ë³ùªk°|©M¤ñ§Q®Éªk°|¹ï©ó¨È°¨»¹¦¹ºØ²V¦X¼Ò¦¡¡A¥ç§Y¡Aº[¸gÀç¦Û®a½u¤WÁʪ«ºô¯¸¡A¤S¦P®É´£¨Ñ²Ä¤T¤è½æ®a¾P°âªº¹q¤l¥«¶°¥¥xªA°È¡A¬O§_n±N²Ä¤T¤è½æ®aªº·~±·í¦¨¨È°¨»¹¦Û¤vªº¡u°Ó¼Ð¨Ï¥Î¤§«IÅv¡v·P¨ì§x´b¡C¦]¦Ó¥Ó½Ð²¾°e¼Ú¬wªk°|¡A¸ÑÄÀ¼Ú·ù°Ó¼Ð³W³¹¡]Regulation 2017/1001¡^²Ä9±ø(2)ªº°Ó¼Ð¨Ï¥Îªº·§©À[4]¡C
Louboutin¥D±i¡A³o¨Ç²£«~¦b¨È°¨»¹ºô¯¸¤Wªº¾P°â¶±¡A´N¬O¤@ºØ¼s§i¡Aºc¦¨¤F°Ó¼Ð¤§¨Ï¥Î¡A¥B¥¼±o¨ì¥L¦P·N¡C¨ä»{¬°¡A¨È°¨»¹¹ï¾ãÓ¥æ©öªº°Ñ»P§êºt¤F¿n·¥¨¤¦â¡A¥B°Ó«~¶±§@¬°¼s§i¡A¤]¬O¨È°¨»¹°Ó·~³q°T¡]commercial communication¡^ªº¤@³¡¥÷[5]¡C¦¹¥~¡A¨È°¨»¹¤]´À²Ä¤T¤è½æ®a®w¦s¡B±H°e¡B°t°e°Ó«~¡A¤]ÄÝ©ó°Ó¼Ð¤§¨Ï¥Î[6]
¼Ú¬wªk°|2011¦~L'Or Áal and Others®×©M2020¦~Coty Germany®×
¹L¥h¼Ú¬wªk°|¹ï©ó½u¤W¥¥xªº°Ó¼Ð«IÅv°ÝÃD¡A´¿°µ¹L¤GÓ«n§P¨M¡C
²Ä¤@Ó§P¨M¬O2011¦~ªºL'Or Áal and Others v. eBay®×¡C¸Ó®×¤¤¡A½u¤W¥¥x¦bGoogle¤WÀ°²Ä¤T¤è½æ®a¥´¼s§i¡A¥Ñ©ó¦Û¤v¦³§êºt¿n·¥¨¤¦â¡A´N¤£¯à¥D±i¥¥x§K³d¡C
¦b¥»®×¤¤¡A¨È°¨»¹¨Ã¨S¦³À°²Ä¤T¤è½æ®a¥´¼s§i¡AY®M¥ÎL'Or Áal and Others®×ªº¨£¸Ñ¡A¨È°¨»¹¦ü¥G¤£¥Ît³d¡C¦b¥»®×ªº°ÝÃD¬O¡A²Ä¤T¤è½æ®a¦b¨È°¨»¹ºô¯¸ªº°Ó«~¶±¡A©M¨È°¨»¹¾ãÓºô¯¸¬Ûµ²¦X¡A³o¼Ëªº°Ó«~¶±¡Aºâ¬O¨È°¨»¹¦b¥´¼s§i¶Ü¡H
²Ä¤GÓ§P¨M¬O2020¦~Coty Germany®×¡A¸Ó®×§iªº´N¬O¨È°¨»¹¡C·í®É¼Ú¬wªk°|»{¬°¡AY¥u¬O³æ¯Â®w¦s¡A¦Ó¨S¦³´£¨Ñ±H°eªA°È¡A«h¤£ºc¦¨«IÅv¡C
¦b¥»®×¤¤¡ALouboutin¥D±i¡A¨È°¨»¹¨Ã«D³æ¯Â´À²Ä¤T¤è½æ®aÀx¦s¡AÁÙ´À²Ä¤T¤è½æ®a°t°e³fª«¡C¼Ú¬wªk°|»¡©ú¡A2020¦~Coty Germany®×¡A·í®É¤D´L«¼w°êªk°|ªº»{©w¡A»{¬°¨È°¨»¹¥u¦³Àx¦s¨S¦³°t°e[7]¡C¦ý¬O¦b¥»®×¤¤¡A¦pªG¦U°êªk°|¹ï©ó¨Æ¹ê¦³¤£¦P»{©w¡A¥i¯à¦³·|¥X²{¤£¦Pµ²ªG¡C
¼Ú¬wªk°|ªºÃöÁä§Pã
¼Ú¬wªk°|«ü¥X¡A¼Ú·ù°Ó¼Ð³W³¹¡]Regulation 2017/1001¡^²Ä9±ø(2)ªº°Ó¼Ð¨Ï¥Î¡Aªí¥Ün¦³¿n·¥¦æ¬°¡A¥B¯àª½±µ©Î¶¡±µ±±¨î²Ä9±ø(3)©Ò¨Ò¥Ü¤§¦U¶µ¨Ï¥Î¦æ¬°[8]¡Cªk°|»{¬°¡A²Ä9±øªº¥Øªº´N¬On½á¤©°Ó¼ÐÅv¤H«I®`±Æ°£½Ð¨DÅv¡A¬JµM¦p¦¹¡A©Ò´£§iªº¹ï¶H¡A¥²¶·¯à°÷ª½±µ©Î±±¨î¨º¨Ç¦æ¬°¡A¤~¯à°÷°±¤î¨º¨Ç¦æ¬°Ä~Äò¥X²{[9]¡C
¼Ú¬wªk°|¤]«ü¥X¡A©Ò¿×ªº°Ó¼Ð¨Ï¥Î¡A¥²¶·³Q§i±N°Ó¼Ð¨Ï¥Î©ó¡u°Ó·~³q°T¡v¡]commercial communication¡^[10]¡C¦]¦Ó¡A¦b2011¦~ªºL'Or Áal and Others®×¤¤¡Aªk°|»{¬°¡Aì«h¤W²Ä¤T¤è½æ®a¦b½u¤W¥¥xªA¤Wªº¾P°â¸ê°T¡A¨Ã¤£ºâ¬O½u¤W¥¥x°È´£¨ÑªÌ¦b¡u¨Ï¥Î¸Ó°Ó¼Ð¡v¡A¦]¬°²Ä¤T¤è½æ®aªº¾P°â¸ê°T¡A¤£ºâ¬O½u¤W¥¥x¦Û¤v»P®ø¶OªÌªº¡u°Ó·~³q°T¡v[11]¡C
¤@¯ëª¾±¡²z©Ê®ø¶OªÌªº»{ª¾¬OÃöÁä
¼Ú¬wªk°|»{¬°¡A¦pªG¤@ÓªA°È´£¨ÑªÌ´£¨ÑªA°È®É¡A°Ó¼Ðªº¨Ï¥Î¤è¦¡·|Åý®ø¶OªÌ»{¬°¡A¸Ó°Ó¼Ð»P¸ÓªA°È´£¨ÑªÌ©Ò´£¨ÑªA°È¶¡¦s¦b¬YºØ³sµ²¡]establishes a link¡^¡A´N¬O¸ÓªA°È´£¨ÑªÌ¦Û¤v¦b¨Ï¥Î¸Ó°Ó¼Ð[12]¡C¤]´N¬O»¡¡A¦b§PÂ_¬O§_¬°¹q¤l¥«¶°Àç¹BªÌ¦Û¤vªº¡u°Ó·~³q°T¡v¡A¥²¶·n±q¤@¯ëª¾±¡»P²z©Ê®ø¶OªÌªº¨¤«×¨Ó¬Ý¡A¥L̬O§_¹ï¸Ó½u¤W¥¥xªA°È»P¨tª§°Ó¼Ð³Q¨Ï¥Îªº±¡ªp¡A»{¬°¦s¦b¬YºØ³sµ²[13]¡C
¥Ñ©ó¨È°¨»¹ºô¯¸¬J¬O½u¤WÁʪ«ºô¯¸¡A¤S¬O¹q¤l¥«¶°¥¥x¡A§PÂ_ÃöÁä¦b©ó¡A¤@¯ëª¾±¡²z©Ê®ø¶OªÌ¬Ý¨ì¨È°¨»¹ºô¯¸¤W²Ä¤T¤è½æ®aªº¾P°â¶±¨Ï¥Î¨ì¨tª§°Ó¼Ð®É¡A¬O§_·|»{¬°²Ä¤T¤è½æ®aªº¾P°â¶±¤w¸g¾ã¦X¶i¨È°¨»¹ºô¯¸ªº°Ó·~³q°Tªº¤@³¡¥÷¡H®ø¶OªÌ¬O§_·|»{¬°¤GªÌ¦s¦b¤@³sµ²¡A¬O¨È°¨»¹¦Û¤v¥Î¦Û¤vªº¦W¦r¦b³c°â¨tª§²£«~¡H[14]
®ø¶OªÌ¥i¯à·|»{¬°¬O¨È°¨»¹¦b¨Ï¥Î°Ó¼Ð
¼Ú¬wªk°|¦Û¤v¤wµ¹¥Xªì¨Bµª®×¡C
¤@¡A¥Ñ©ó¨È°¨»¹¦b¶±³]p¤W¡A¤£½×¦Û®a°Ó«~ªº§e²{¡AÁÙ¬O²Ä¤T¤è½æ®aªº§e²{¡A³£¥H¤@Pªº§e²{¤è¦¡¡A¨Ã¥B±N¦Û¤v§@¬°ª¾¦W°t°eªÌªºlogo©ñ¦b¨C¤@Ó¾P°â¶±¡A³o·|Åý¤@¯ëª¾±¡²z©Ê®ø¶OªÌÃø¥H°Ï¤À¨ì©³°Ó«~¨Ó¦Û©ó½Ö¡A©Î·|»{¬°³£¬O¨È°¨»¹¦Û¤v¦b¦æ¾P¸Ó²£«~[15]¡C
¤G¡A¨È°¨»¹¹ï²Ä¤T¤è½æ®a©Ò´£¨ÑªA°È¡AÁÙ¥]¬AÀx¦s¡B±H°e³fª«¡B°h³fªA°Èµ¥¡A³£·|Åý¤@¯ëª¾±¡²z©Ê®ø¶O³o»{¬°¡A³o¨Ç³fª«¬O¨È°¨»¹¥H¦Û¤v¦W¸q¡B¬°¦Û¤v§Q¯q©Ò´£¨Ñ¡A¦]¦ÓÅý®ø¶OªÌ»{¬°¡A³o¨ÇªA°È»P¨tª§°Ó«~¡B°Ó¼Ð¦³³sµ²[16]¡C
¼Ú¬wªk°|´£¥X¼Ð·Ç«á¡A±N¦¹®×µo¦^¿c´Ë³ù©M¤ñ§Q®Éªk°|¥h°µ¨Æ¹ê»{©w¡C¦ý±q¼Ú¬wªk°|©Ò´£¥X¤Wz¼Ð·Ç¡Aªk°|«Ü¥i¯à·|»{©w¡A¨È°¨»¹ªº²V¦X¤è¦¡¤£®e©öÅý®ø¶OªÌ°Ï¤À¬O³æ¯Â»P²Ä¤T¤è½æ®a¥æ©ö¡C¤]´N¬O»¡¡A¨È°¨»¹ªº¦¹ºØ¤è¦¡¡A«Ü¦³¥i¯àn¬°½æ®aªº°Ó¼Ð«IÅv¦æ¬°t³d¡C
³Æµù¡G
- C-148/21 - Louboutin (Use of an infringing sign on an online market) ,Judgment ECLI:EU:C:2022:1016.
- Id. para 12.
- Id. paras 6-7.
- Id. para 23.
- Id. para 11.
- Id para 11.
- Id. praras 32-33.
- Id. para 27.
- Id. para 28.
- Id. para 29.
- Id. para 30.
- Id. para 40.
- Id. paras 43, 46.
- Id. para 48.
- Id. para 51.
- Id. para 53.